Tagged with Shadi Hamid

Rethinking Political Islam, but then What?

Rethinking Political Islam, but then What?

The first part of the title is the name of a very good explanatory piece in The Islamic Monthly. It also is the name of a new book by Shadi Hamid and Will McCants, collecting analysis from Islamists published individually at Brookings. The trouble is, this article leaves me with more questions. First the good stuff: In … Continue reading

Concerning Islamism: Hands On or Off?

Concerning Islamism: Hands On or Off?

Shadi Hamid of the Brookings Institute is an insightful analyst of Middle Eastern affairs. Of Islamists in particular, he notes they often moderate under moderate repression, as witnessed under Mubarak. But intrinsically he finds them to be ‘illiberal’ in terms of Western values, though there is a strong undercurrent in his writing that the values … Continue reading